Candidate proposals for change: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 07:35, 22 February 2017

Current state of OAIS review

Over 150 changes were suggested for the review of the OAIS 2012 standard version. The CCSDS working group is currently working on a new draft. It is still possible to participate in the discussions about the suggested changes.

How to follow the review process

Discussion directly related to the official review process of OAIS issues will be accessible via the http://review.oais.info.

If you want to see all issues just enter “OAIS” in the “Quick Search” text field and press “Quick Search” You can now see the comments and discussion of an issue by clicking on an issue.

If you want to add a comment to an issue – or be mailed when there are changes – then you will need to make a login. You can create an account for login by pressing “New Account” in the top bar and follow the instructions.

After login:

You can add comments by ”Add Comment” under ”Additional Comments”)
You can follow issue by marking the box after “CC List:” (Add me to CC list)

The below issues have been added their respective issue URL on http://review.oais.info

Proposals

Other topics/blogs that are not covered fully

Appearance on wiki as	Area	Comment
Topic Nestor	OAIS in relation to other standards	Partly covered by Proposal: The Family of OAIS Standard proposal
Topic Nestor	Significant Properties vs. Transformational Information Properties
Topic Nestor	OAIS and the PREMIS concepts "Intellectual Entity" and "Representation"	Partly covered by Proposal: The Family of OAIS Standard proposal (related to Blog PREMIS and OAIS below)
Blog PREMIS and OAIS	PREMIS and OAIS	Partially covered by The Family of OAIS Standard proposal
Topic Nestor	Integration of Lifecycle Management into OAIS / Pre-Ingest	(related to Blog Pre-ingest)
Blog Pre-ingest	Pre-ingest	Not easy to formalize as there do not seem to be agreement on what this is, and line to e.g. PAIMAS is not clear.
Topic Nestor	Ideas relating to AIP Update, AIP Delete und AIP Transfer
Topic DEPIP	New upcoming ISo Standard DEPIP	Could be included in the Proposal: The Family of OAIS Standards
Blog Preservation Watch	Preservation Watch
Blog The case for a revision of OAIS	The case for a revision of OAIS	Partly covered by the Outer OAIS – Inner OAIS for description of distributed digital preservation Proposal. (see also Comments on David Rosenthal's "The case for a revision of OAIS")
Blog Visualizing OAIS	Visualizing OAIS	Partly covered by the Visualizing OAIS – Revised functions diagram proposal
Topic Minimal Effort Ingest	Minimal Effort Ingest	Implicitly and conceptually covered by the Outer OAIS – Inner OAIS for description of distributed digital preservation proposal with Ingest represented by an Inner OAIS
Topic Representation Information	Software, that is part of an object's Representation Information, should be considered part of the digital object itself
Topics Add Data Curation	Terminology extended with a definition of Data Curation - see discussion tab
Topic encryption	Add language that specifically addresses the issue of encryption
Topic 'active'/'inactive' AIP	Consider distinguishing between an 'active AIP' and an 'inactive AIP'
Topic DIP design	Clarify where in model DIP design takes place
Topic transform SIP/AIP into DIP	Specify that an OAIS must have the technological capability to transform a SIP or AIP into a DIP
Topic Add "lien" definition	Add a definition to the glossary for "lien" as it is used in the context of the standard
Topic Transfer Information Package	Transfer Information Package
Topic Add Selection and Appraisal	Selection and Appraisal in the OAIS Model - issues of granularity in relation to pre-ingest

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-== UNDER CONSTRUCTION ==
+== Current state of OAIS review ==
+Over 150 changes were suggested for the review of the OAIS 2012 standard version. The CCSDS working group is currently working on a new draft. It is still possible to participate in the discussions about the suggested changes.
+== How to follow the review process ==
+Discussion directly related to the official review process of OAIS issues will be accessible via the http://review.oais.info.
+If you want to see all issues just enter “OAIS” in the “Quick Search” text field and press “Quick Search”
+You can now see the comments and discussion of an issue by clicking on an issue.
-== Time for action! ==
+If you want to add a comment to an issue – or be mailed when there are changes – then you will need to make a login. You can create an account for login by pressing “New Account” in the top bar and follow the instructions.
-The DPC OAIS Community Wiki now has a page where proposals can be discussed before they are officially submitted to the OAIS 2012 review process: http://wiki.dpconline.org/index.php?title=Candidate_proposals_for_change
+After login:
-This page will contain links to draft proposals for candidates, posted by authors who would like feedback from the community. Please use the discussion tab to give your feedback on the proposal.
+*You can add comments by ”Add Comment” under ”Additional Comments”)
+*You can follow issue by marking the box after “CC List:” (Add me to CC list)
-Ultimately you should submit your proposals for changes of the OAIS 2012 version to the official review website at http://review.oais.info/. But if you would like to discuss your proposed changes within the community before submitting an official review proposal you can post your proposal to the wiki, where the discussions can take place behind the discussion tab.
+The below issues have been added their respective issue URL on http://review.oais.info
 == Proposals ==
@@ Line 66: / Line 70: @@
 | Blog [[The_case_for_a_revision_of_OAIS|The case for a revision of OAIS]]
 | The case for a revision of OAIS
-| (see also [[Comments_on_David_Rosenthal%27s_%E2%80%9CThe_case_for_a_revision_of_OAIS%E2%80%9D|Comments on David Rosenthal's "The case for a revision of OAIS"]])
+| Partly covered by the [[Outer_OAIS_–_Inner_OAIS_proposal| Outer OAIS – Inner OAIS for description of distributed digital preservation]] Proposal. (see also [[Comments_on_David_Rosenthal%27s_%E2%80%9CThe_case_for_a_revision_of_OAIS%E2%80%9D|Comments on David Rosenthal's "The case for a revision of OAIS"]])
 |-
 | Blog [[Visualizing_OAIS|Visualizing OAIS]]